Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by noitsnot 2835 days ago
The movie theatre experience is one of a kind. You can't come close to re-creating it with your phone or tv.
3 comments

I would have agreed when I was a kid and a huge TV was a 27" 480i CRT. But now you can get a 85" 4k HDR screen at home, I'd say you can come close. Better than many theaters.
It's not only the A/V that goes into the experience. Not saying it is a perfect experience, but a large TV or even a projector isn't really the same.
Indeed. It is the same as saying that one should never go out for a walk, because you can easily walk some rounds around the table in the comfort of your own house.

It's the 'out' part that is important!

Except a theater isn't out, you are just trading one dark room for another.
The theater itself is not the experience. The 'out' thing is, though.
You can still have the "out", like Dinner and coffee at a restaurant. But the specific watching a movie part is "in" whether it is at a theater or your living room.
Bikeshedding
You committed the fallacy of posting a fallacy without support.

In a theater, you sit in the dark, if you are a good citizen, you don't talk. 90% of any social piece to going to a movies happens at dinner before or after, which you can still do and then go home to watch a movie.

My 9 foot projection screen with dolby surround sound in my light controlled living room would say otherwise.
You can with a VR headset though.
I think the StarVR will get there one day. Here's a review of it: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GvFBUvfpQJ8

The only problem is right now they are targeting business, but I hope to see a consumer version one day and if they can get it lighter, comfortable for 3 hours of continuous wearing and can replace a theatre screen.

I don't see why it can't replace a TV or movie experience.

Most movie theaters don't give me headaches and make me feel like I'm getting carsick.
Carsick?? Why would 1 to 1 movement make you carsick?

Are you talking about gearvr? Or other “not really vr” headsets?

None of them are hi-res enough to really do that job.