Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by esdkl22 2839 days ago
I have a question about point #12. Are most people in agreement that the if else loop is preferrable over a ternary operator?

One of my worst professional programming experiences was having a senior developer who took apart usage of map, filter, reduce, and replaced them with if else loops, and sometimes breaking things in the process.

The idea that you would one day have a junior who would fail to understand a relatively simple concept seems like fantasy. Let them get stumped once, and then teach!

1 comments

no, but it all comes to the complexity of the operation.

Like the article said, something like this is better than an if else loop: $variable == $x ? $y : $z;

But if you write stuff like this:

$variable == $x ? ($x == $y ? array_merge($x, $y, $z) : $x) : $y;

I am going to be annoyed. In the second case, please use if else.

You're correct. I didn't look closely enough at the finalized piece of code. I misinterpreted and thought the offer was unsatisfied with the original, appropriate use for a ternary operator ($variable == $x ? $y : $z)