[mannimow]

Mac re-design sure looks like a 3rd party Firefox theme from 2014. I know it's subjective, so that's my personal opinion.

But is it in line with Material design? Or is Chrome not subject to these guidelines?

If you open settings, or downloads window in Chrome, you'll see it has blue bars, rounded edges, shadows.

Compare to this re-design, large radius rounded edges, entirely flat looking buttons and inputs.

I honestly though for a second I opened Firefox accidentally with another theme pre-installed.