Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by overgard 2851 days ago
It’s better than every other build system, but god I wish they had just used a preexisting language for it. The syntax for CMake just feels so janky and weird, and it’s another set of things I have to remember and (eventually) forget. It’s not like it has these amazing language concepts nothing else can do; and if they’re worried about size or dependencies something like Lua would add like no overhead and be super simple to link.
2 comments
DoofusOfDeath 2850 days ago
I agree. CMake's scripting language has a lot of the same pain-points as Bash. For example, the lack of a clear distinction between lists and strings.

I've sometimes wondered if CMake would benefit from getting an additional / replacement scripting language. While retaining the same underlying object model and other code, that is.

My only fear would be that it would be a first step in morphing into Bazel, which I find unbearably complicated.

link
DoofusOfDeath 2850 days ago
Clarification: I know that Bash has arrays. But environment variables such as "PATH" use colon-separated strings.
link
ur-whale 2850 days ago
Couldn't agree more.

Any system that designs its own DSL should be suspect: designing languages is bloody hard, and anyone who think he can cobble his own to solve a problem as hard as build systems is doomed to produce something like cmake.

link
whyever 2850 days ago
It's kind of a historical accident. Originally, CMake was supposed to be just a list of commands (CMakeLists.txt). Of course, it was heavily extended to what we have now.
link
rutthenut 2850 days ago
Do understand that things change over time, from simple beginnings to complex offspring. But I agree with many commenters here; it is frustrating and a ball-ache to have to learn yet another syntax to manage build dependencies and instructions. On that, I also detest how YAML, Python and so on make space indentation a core aspect of how the files are interpreted and processed. That idea stinks. imvho.
link
whyever 2849 days ago
> it is frustrating and a ball-ache to have to learn yet another syntax to manage build dependencies and instructions.

Oh, I agree as well. I was just providing context.

link