Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by erw1 2855 days ago
If you expect people to stop doing something disagreeable, you better make sure you are not deeply engaged in the same type of behavior. That seems fairly straight-forward.
1 comments

It's not straightforward - that's exactly the point of the tu quoque fallacy.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tu_quoque

As an individual American who is not involved in intelligence or military work, I can condemn such actions by any nation while maintaining moral consistency.

The point of that wiki article (tu quoque fallacy) is that the critic's moral character is irrelevant. The whole point is that you don't need 'moral consistency' to critique bad behavior.

So then why do you feel the need to justify yourself by saying that you don't work in defense? :) You basically stepped into the same trap you warmed me against :) Maintaining moral high ground seems to be a vital need, something on the level of instinct it seems. 'Tu quoque' or no 'tu quoque' we like to feel morally justified.