Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by emodendroket 2858 days ago
But long-range trucking seems just as amenable to replacement by freight trains if we're building dedicated infrastructure.
2 comments

1. Building railroads is an order of magnitude harder than building roads (gradients, turn radii, clearance, yards).

2. Not even building, just repurposing. "This road/lane/whatever now SDV only."

3. Trains only run on rails. Trucks that could be run as SDVs on dedicated infrastructure and as human-driven on shared infrastructure tackle the last-mile problem far more efficiently.

4. Trains are built on the "smart infrastructure" paradigm (go straight at the speed which the signals tell you, until the signals tell you to stop); trucks on the opposite "smart vehicles" paradigm (road exists, everything else is your responsibility). This makes a truck rollout far more scalable (as in "just add this road to whitelist").

Trains don't run on demand from point to point. All your Amazon next day deliveries depend on trucks and airplanes.

Trains work for some freight delivery patterns, but not nearly all. Stuff that can go by train for the most part already does.