[hobls]

Of course it’s disputed. There are lots of happy employees of tech giants. Any company with thousands and thousands of employees is going to have a wide variety of teams of varying qualities.

(And yeah, the pay makes a difference. Not a lot of places where you can make a few hundred thousand dollars a year.)

[mlthoughts2018]

I work for a large tech company and don’t know of any company like that with a large number of employees happy with their company.

(I’m making a distinction between the idea that a job “is fine” where one “is happy” merely because the culture is at least not worse than elsewhere while the pay is better vs actually feeling positively about one’s company’s culture and corporate behavior.

For example, my friends who work at Facebook are “happy” with their jobs, mostly because of pay and because they know if they switch to other companies, politics, corporate misbehavior, etc., will just continue. But these same people tell me frequently how sad, upset, soulless, disappointed they regularly feel because of their employer.

That feeling I think is extremely widespread in tech, almost all employers. That’s the only part in my viewpoint that matters for whether someone “is happy” at their job, and it’s that type of bad culture I think can be easily flagged by little stuff, like bad whiteboard interviews.)

[JoeAltmaier]

I blame the modern attempt to turn software developers into assembly-line workers. With sprints and tasks and momentum and a million tiny cuts that take the innovation out and replace it with anonymous criticism and process over product.

[mlthoughts2018]

I largely agree. Modern companies are set up to cargo cult lots of process and pay lip-service to innovation while taking extremely risk-averse and conservative approaches to practically everything they do.

Nobody has any idea what’s going on; nobody has clarity. And when someone does have clarity, middle management is only interested if they can set it up like a battery to harvest credit from. If they can’t, their incentives are usually more aligned with intentionally abusing process to “manage out” innovative people.