[heisenbergs]

That's the wrong analogy. The camera isn't some "security footage" in a random store, it's security footage from my own living room.

A better analogy is this: if i install a video camera in my home and pay a service to store and process that data (think nest cam), but that i'm paying monthly for, then that data should be mine. Stuff going on in my living room (aka my music listening habits) should be mine and i should have access to my habits and restrict others from using it if i want to.

Update: more importantly, without having access to data stored by any service, i can't make an informed decision as to whether the service is storing dubious information about myself that it shouldn't. Services can no longer hide the data they store about people.

[nickysielicki]

None of these analogies make any sense or have any relevance to the nature of what's going on when you use a service. Fundamentally you are sending requests from your computer to their computers, and their computers are sending things back to your computer in response. They have every right to log what activities their own computers are doing, and (in my mind) they have every right to claim sole ownership over the logs that they create.

The fact that they have to legally release this kind of thing is really twisted, at least to me. If you want to have logs of your listening data --- if you want to have logs of what your computer is doing --- how about you log it yourself? If that's too much work for you, whose fault is that? Don't use it if you don't like it.

Music services are a dime a dozen nowadays. The biggest reason that any given consumer stays with a given service has to do with recommendations and playlists and the profile that they've built on you. The fact that these companies now have to give that data back to consumers, which they could presumably feed into another (cheaper) service, disincentivizes companies from building better recommendation engines and down the line it ultimately makes for a worse experience for music listeners.

[_r_o_y_]

With that logic you could argue that almost nothing should be regulated, as the "work" nowadays is always done by someone else, what is the different between this and a credit score?