[cube2222]

This would be blatantly illegal (especially with GDPR) and if exposed, would be the end of their company. (As security is their main focus)

I'm not using protonmail myself, but I'm sure they're not playing around with your data.

[jolmg]

Switzerland is not part of the EU, though. Enforcement of GDPR on them depends on how well the EU can force their laws on non-EU nations, something which I hope cannot be done. Who wants to abide by the laws of others in their own home without even the chance to somehow vote or otherwise affect them?

[cube2222]

The US isn't either. GDPR applies to all companies doing business in the EU and handling EU user data.

I'm not saying if it's good or not, but if they wouldn't abide, they'd be blocked from doing business in the EU.

They have a gdpr section on their webpage by the way.

[jolmg]

> GDPR applies to all companies doing business in the EU and handling EU user data.

Only because the EU said it does. I don't think any country, the US included, agreed to abide by their laws. No one has such a treaty that somehow includes the GDPR, as far as I know. I can only imagine their only way of enforcing it is by using their economic strength as leverage and threatening to place tariffs on some export or import or such.

> I'm not saying if it's good or not, but if they wouldn't abide, they'd be blocked from doing business in the EU.

Is that the plan? Put up a giant firewall around the whole EU, heuristically blocking foreign businesses that didn't comply?

As far as I know, they "require" world internet businesses to have a company branch physically in the EU, but how are they going to enforce that? They put fines on violations, but are they really planning to go to any nation in the world and enforce payment, citing law that's foreign to the citizens of that land? It seems silly, or unjust and scary if it turns out doable.

EDIT: I'm not necessarily against the GDPR. I think it's a move in the right direction with respect to respecting user data, but I am concerned with the fact that it tries to assign obligations worldwide without being a worldwide treaty. Not that I'm saying that it would be practical (or even a practical possibility) to have a worldwide treaty, but the way this is forced also seems like a move in the wrong direction with respect to world internet unity or international respect for national sovereignty.

[cube2222]

They can probably do the firewall thing and/or block any payments from EU accounts to the company.

We'll see for sure if and when it happens in practice. Though I suppose it won't, any company sizeable enough would lose too big a market this way. And I don't think they'll go after the smaller ones, at least for a while.

I don't like the methods they can try to enforce gdpr with, though I literally love the law itself.

[bartbutler]

This.