Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by reaperducer 2892 days ago
Very tricky. Tourism is still a very big industry in San Francisco. One of the reasons people go there is to see the charming old houses and nice old neighborhoods.

While we think SF would look great if it were like in the Star Trek movies, that would pretty much destroy a large part of what makes San Francisco San Francisco.

5 comments

Think about that for a moment.

People come to SF to visit the attractions at the high density parts e.g fisherman's wharf, union square, chinatown, ghirardelli square, coit tower, etc.

Look at a standard tourist map of SF: https://www.sftodo.com/sanfrancisco/wp-content/uploads/2018/...

No one comes to SF to visit the vast tracts of suburbia in the sunset: https://goo.gl/maps/p91HMQTcXBQ2

There's a high density apartment right next to the famous Painted Ladies, and tourists still come: https://d2v9y0dukr6mq2.cloudfront.net/video/thumbnail/NYb7kU.... Most people aren't for bulldozing landmarks and genuine historical areas, but rather building on mundane areas like old laundromats: https://sf.curbed.com/2018/2/14/17012606/laundromat-2918-mis....
> charming old houses and nice old neighborhoods.

No one comes to outer Richmond, Sunset, or Parkside for the "charming old houses". It's mostly single-family sprawl.

The funny part is there are 6-10 story apartment buildings in Sunset that are illegal to build under current code. Doesn't seem to be "ruining" the neighborhood.

> One of the reasons people go there is to see the charming old houses and nice old neighborhoods

The vast bulk of SF is probably not of any particular interest, though. Most European cities will have areas of historical interest where buildings are protected, sometimes incredibly strictly (here's a 250 year old 8000sqft house which would require 1.5million renovation to make it habitable, due to strict controls on acceptable renovation methods: https://www.independent.ie/life/home-garden/homes/georgian-p...). But that doesn't mean that you can't densify anywhere. Areas of historical importance are normally a small fraction of a city.

I think this tourist map[1] brilliantly depicts what parts most tourists actually stick to, by shrinking the western parts of the city on the map.

There are very few tourists in the vast majority of the Richmond and Sunset, except near the water and Golden Gate Park (around the museums). Also, there are very few tourists south of Bernal Heights Park.

[1] http://baycityguide.com/media/San-Francisco-Map.pdf