Russia was at an average level of development in 1918.
European parts of Russia (St Petersburg) where relatively modern, and
while much of the rest of the country was rural and backwards
* there is no reason whatsoever to assume that it wouldn't have been
developed with other forms of government in Russia, whether under
a Tsar, or -- even better -- a modern western democracy.
* Bolsheviks retarded the development of Russia. All comparable
western nations developed faster, practically all 'Soviet'
technology was basically invented in the west. The Soviets had
nothing to offer but violence.
For example (from [1]): "Russia's population growth rate from 1850 to
1910 was the fastest of all the major powers except for the United
States."
Let me emphasise: I'm not saying that the Tsarist regime was
particularly good, just a lot better than the Bolsheviks. If Russia had stayed Tsarist, or -- even better -- become a normal western democracy, it would have been much better than the Bolshevik rule.
Russia was at an average level of development in 1918. European parts of Russia (St Petersburg) where relatively modern, and while much of the rest of the country was rural and backwards
* there is no reason whatsoever to assume that it wouldn't have been developed with other forms of government in Russia, whether under a Tsar, or -- even better -- a modern western democracy.
* Bolsheviks retarded the development of Russia. All comparable western nations developed faster, practically all 'Soviet' technology was basically invented in the west. The Soviets had nothing to offer but violence.
For example (from [1]): "Russia's population growth rate from 1850 to 1910 was the fastest of all the major powers except for the United States."
Let me emphasise: I'm not saying that the Tsarist regime was particularly good, just a lot better than the Bolsheviks. If Russia had stayed Tsarist, or -- even better -- become a normal western democracy, it would have been much better than the Bolshevik rule.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_Russia_(1855%E2%80%...