Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by omeid2 2904 days ago
> I’ve always been a big believer in rebuilding your product from the ground up. I think it’s something you should always have going on in the background. Just a couple of devs whose job it is to try and rebuild your thing from scratch.

Hahaha. Just a couple of devs?
1 comments
tomelders 2904 days ago
Their job isn’t to build the whole thing. Their job is to research and explore how new ideas and tools might be useful to your business.

It’s just R&D. It’s not an exotic idea.

link
zbentley 2904 days ago
Some of the best colleagues I've had, and teams I have worked with, have made this position (formally or informally) a rotating one. It's a great way to learn.

Corollary: this position needs to be at least two devs. Otherwise, you're rotating in people for redundant discoveries rather than mentorship.

link
omeid2 2904 days ago
The problem with this idea, to put in terms of the main article, is that it raises Red Flag #1.

It may be a great way to learn, but I think that is better achieved with something like Google's famous 20% program not some vague rewrite attempt with no direction.

link
zbentley 2902 days ago
I completely agree. Having a pure-research team with a mandate of "all your research must be geared towards totally reimagining the entire product" is a dumb idea. Having more granular (and collaboratively driven) goals from "some of your research must be geared towards totally rewriting an area of our application that is a major pain point, and for which all previous attempts to do incremental changes have failed for technical reasons" to "look into better tools or strategies we could use to tune performance of, or write better tests for, swaths of existing code" is more realistic and more useful.

Obviously, other, not-pure-research devs should be given time to do some of that work as well, otherwise the research team becomes the "saviors that are always about to come back over the hill" for every other team while they kick their respective cans down the road.

link
repolfx 2903 days ago
That's pretty different to what you were talking about originally. You started by talking about rebuilds and said, have two guys just rebuilding the product. Now you're saying they're doing R&D. Those are very different tasks.
link