Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by user5994461 2897 days ago
Not to be dismissive but better look for an alternative solution. The SAML spec is a beast, you can work on it for months, you will hardly get a few percents of it working.

If you're doing that for a small company, maybe try to get a Microsoft active directory instead. It's a lot easier to setup and maintain and everything does their best to integrate with it.

1 comments

I realize it's a little late to say this, but AD FS is garbage. I've run AD FS both as an InCommon IdP and an InCommon SP, with both as full federation partners. While I solved the metadata consumption, attribute scope checking, and discovery UX issues, I encountered lots of little interoperability issues that required disabling request/assertion encryption or switching between SHA-1/SHA-256 on individual CP/RP trusts. Ultimately, we replaced the IdPs with Shibboleth and moved the SPs behind SATOSA, which works a LOT better.