Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by alanfranzoni 2910 days ago
Slightly off topic: I've always found twitter-style blocking totally nonsensical. I mean: you've got a public account. Blocking should prevent people from replying or tweeting at you, and from sending you DMs, maybe even retweeting what you said (even though I'm not sure about the usefulness of this last thing)... but why should ANYONE be prevented at just READING PUBLIC CONTENT when LOGGED IN?

(I think the same applies for Facebook and yes, I think that's nonsensical as well)
3 comments
bodas 2910 days ago
Twitter realises it is stupid. However many of their technologically illiterate users don't and when they tried to change it there was an outcry that Twitter was helping abuse or something silly like that. Keeping the feature is as is easier than educating their users how computers work.
link
zem 2910 days ago
it raises the friction for people quoting your tweets and encouraging their followers to harass you.
link
alanfranzoni 2910 days ago
Well... raises by how much? Is that really significant? By the way... that's it.
link
zem 2909 days ago
i'm betting it is - it's a classic funnel problem, where the more friction you add to a process the more people will abandon it.
link
TangoTrotFox 2910 days ago
I've also wondered about this, and the only conclusion I could come to is quite cynical. Think about the practical effects. It encourages people to create multiple accounts and also encourages warring of various sorts. These behaviors send Twitter's usage and user numbers up without bots while enabling complete plausible deniability about any complicity. It's a problem with ad-driven networks. Their goal is to increase user numbers which enables them to inflate their advertised reach and thus increase their overall revenue.

One might joke about Facebook bragging about its reach: "We have more than 2 billion users and only 25% are located in the USA!" Subtlety, math, and statistical references all in one one-liner joke - what could be better?

link
Sean1708 2910 days ago
They tried to change the behaviour to the one that makes sense (to us) but there was backlash from users and so they reverted the change.[0]

[0]: https://www.imore.com/twitter-changes-how-block-works-heres-...

link
alanfranzoni 2910 days ago
I didn't know that. Well, ok.
link