[saudioger]

The study tested people who would lose access to the photos immediately or delete them intentionally, and they still succumbed to the effect... so I'd expect it would be similar for analog.

I think the the more important distinction you mentioned is that photographers who are a bit beyond amateur are more likely to analyze what they're shooting, and therefore remember it.

[seba_dos1]

They have still seen them after taking, which is what might actually be a trigger for the discussed offloading effect.