Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by ScottAaronson 2912 days ago
Sure, you could shake off the idea (if you haven't already...) that quantum entanglement means communication faster than light. This is, interestingly, exactly the same kind of error as the one that says that a quantum computer is just like a classical computer but with exponential parallelism. Namely, you look at the resources that would be needed to simulate a quantum system using a classical system (faster-than-light communication in the one case, exponential parallelism in the other). You then confuse those with the resources that the quantum system itself provides you.

In reality, quantum mechanics is carving out a third profile of abilities, which is neither as weak as the classical profile, nor as strong as the thing that people mistakenly overcorrect to once you tell them that the classical profile is inadequate. E.g., you can violate the Bell inequality but NOT send instantaneous signals; you can solve factoring in polynomial time but probably NOT NP-complete problems. As I like to say (someone already quoted it elsewhere), it's a sufficiently strange state of affairs that no science-fiction writer would have had the imagination to invent it.