[stillkicking]

"How can a site be both a Church of SJWs and an alt-right shithole?"

If one side is committed to flagging content off into invisibility, and another is committed to debating that practice, then you end up with this situation. There does not need to be any symmetry in behavior, and it does not mean the site is both or either of those things.

It just means you have some religious SJWs who call everything they disagree with alt-right, regardless of people's actual political self-identification or their desired policies. It means that SJW tactics are allowed to work, and that they are successfully casting the blame onto their own targets. It's like a social prisoner's dilemma where one defector castigates the other for not cooperating.

I invite you to show posts that advocate SJW ideas in a polite and neutral tone that have been flagged off the front-page, rather than debated. Given that opponents of SJWism tend to favor free expression on principle, I highly doubt you can find them in any number.

If you don't want the meta, keep the object-level clean.