Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by paulie_a 2928 days ago
Tldr: Disney committed lemming genocide
2 comments

Why the downvotes?

From White Wilderness, as the movie shows drowning Lemmings, put there by Disney employees, the narrator goes:

"And so is acted out, the legend of mass suicide and destruction of a species."

https://youtu.be/xMZlr5Gf9yY?t=2m50s

>Why the downvotes?

Probably because it's inaccurate/exaggerated in a couple ways.

1. Genocide refers to humans, not animals, and requires the act to be targeted at a group of people that share some sort of traits (typically race, or cultural identity).

2. Disney imported "no more than a few dozen lemmings," which doesn't really meet the numbers the word typically is used for.

https://www.snopes.com/fact-check/white-wilderness/

Disney killed lemmings, and unless they attempted to wipe out all lemmings that share a particular cultural identity, it's probably pretty insensitive to use it in this context.

Genocide is by definition against a group having common genetic/ethnic identity.

One might also consider that animals are people, too.

However, I don't think you can make the case that Disney set out to wipe lemmings from the earthwe.

Wouldn't xenocide be a more apt description? A quick search for genocide gives the definition of:

"the deliberate killing of a large group of people, especially those of a particular ethnic group or nation."

While xenocide is described as:

xenocide (plural xenocides)

The killing of a stranger or foreigner. (science fiction) The genocide of an entire alien species. (US, colloquial) The intentional killing of an entire foreign (plant or animal) species.

https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/xenocide

Either is fine really, just seems like a semantic curiosity.

Probably -- the problem is that no one actually knows the word xenocide who isn't an Orson Scott Card fan.
Why? Genocide is by derivation the killing or wiping out of a genetic population. Why can’t that be applied to purposeful extinction of an animal species?