[rpedela]

> The ones that pay are not the ones that receive the benefit.

Again, that is factually and objectively incorrect. I even gave you a personal example where I pay and I benefit. You are entitled to your own opinions but not your own facts.

[conanbatt]

Thats you, does every single payer receive the benefit? And does the benefit outstrip the cost?

If the latter is true, there is no need for a tax: the government can sell it optionally and every single payer would subscribe to it. The tax is only necessary to collect the money from people that would not pay for it.