[nonbel]

This sounds like standard biomed to me:

  - Refusal to share data
  - Refusal to share data analysis methods
  - Not keeping the basics of a double-blinded test
  - No reproduction, and not even the possibility of independent reproducibility, as the methods are described so vaguely.

Can you link to a recent paper that doesnt run afoul of at least one of your criteria. Especially the last...