[speedplane]

It's more than a logical or performance issue, it's a cultural one. In C culture, there's a sense that the programmer has direct control over the hardware. They can literally write or read to any memory address as they see fit, and have very fine-grained control over what the machine is doing.

Modern processors, with their out-of-order execution, complex caching algorithms, deep pipeliens and multi-threaded hardware often render this sense of control more illusory than factual, but the C culture remains wedded to the idea that the programmer is in control.

Accordingly, it's pretty provocative to suggest that a compiler or runtime would zero out memory without you specifically saying so. Any C programmer can overload malloc (doesn't zero memory) to calloc (which does). Whether it's a good or bad idea to do so is up to the programmer. The overall idea is don't do anything unless I say so.