Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by guelo 2946 days ago
A simple blog without ads still collects IP addresses. It's as if the EU is trying to legislate that the web needs to behave like Tor.
2 comments

IP addresses are not PII unless you also have timestamps and a legal avenue for querying the ISP records to see which account and thus person was behind the IP address at that time.

As a small blog, no ISP is going to give you the time of day, so it's not PII because you have no avenue for converting it to a person. If you transmit that data (say to google analytics) it might /become/ PII because google (or any other person you transmit it to) may combine it with other data they have access to, to turn it into PII.

The reasons large organizations are fretting about IP addresses are thus:

a) They have IP/timestamp records going back years, maybe decades

b) They may have ISPs willing to talk to them about who had the IP address at a specific time

c) They can't confidently allow that data to pass to partners in case their partners have access to ISP records

d) That data is a ticking timebomb, because even if they don't have an agreement with an ISP now, if an ISP offers that service for free to all takers in the future, their trove of IP/timestamp pairs could suddenly become PII overnight through no action from them

So yeah, for businesses operating at a certain scale, IP/timestamp combos are now a toxic asset. That doesn't mean your log files for your blog are suddenly a GDPR violation, unless you share them with people or have an inside track with a local ISP.

You can read more here: https://www.whitecase.com/publications/alert/court-confirms-...

Doesn't point (d) apply equally to organizations of all sizes?
> still collects IP addresses

It doesn't have to.