Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by dmortin 2952 days ago
> AND you can NOT deny me reading an article without giving consent

They can't, but they can, for example, ask for a fee to read the article. They don't deny you reading it, but they don't have to give it to you for free either.

Either you share your data, so they can make money to operate the site, or you don't, but then the content is not free.

I expect some sites will choose this route.

1 comments

> They can't, but they can, for example, ask for a fee to read the article. They don't deny you reading it, but they don't have to give it to you for free either.

Of course they can charge a fee. They should.

> Either you share your data, so they can make money to operate the site, or you don't, but then the content is not free.

No. My data is not a commodity exchange. The GDPR makes that VERY clear. I can not pay with my data. Full stop. There is money for that.

You can pay with your data if you consent to it. It's your data, your choice. But if you don't consent then prepare your credit card for payment.

Most people then will choose the free version.

As y0ghur7_xxx is saying, you cannot pay with your data, just as you cannot take a loan with an interest rate of 1000%, since that would be usury. Even if you signed a contract agreeing to such terms, they don't count as they are not legal.

Contracts don't make laws. Laws make laws. You cannot pay with your data.

> You can pay with your data if you consent to it.

No I can not. I can pay with money. User data is not money.

You are wrong. The entire point of the law is to stop this being an option.