Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by sykh 2955 days ago
Once I earn the money it is my money and no longer taxpayer money. I fund the union with my money. The union does not receive money apportioned by the government.

Is the landlord I rent from supported by taxpayer money because I’m a public employee that rents from him?
1 comments
chimeracoder 2955 days ago
> Once I earn the money it is my money and no longer taxpayer money. I fund the union with my money. The union does not receive money apportioned by the government.

You can't have it both ways. If it's the employee's money, they have the right to do what they want with it, whether that means giving a portion to a union or keeping it for themselves.

If they don't have that legal right, then the money isn't theirs, and it's coming from taxpayers, because it's paid by the government.

link
sykh 2955 days ago
I’m not having anything two ways. Here are two statements which are not contradictory.

1. Unions are not government funded. 2. Those who benefit from collective bargaining ought to help pay for it.

link
s73v3r_ 2955 days ago
That's pretty spurious reasoning. Do I not have the right to do what I want with my money because I have to give part of it to my landlord?
link
chimeracoder 2955 days ago
> That's pretty spurious reasoning. Do I not have the right to do what I want with my money because I have to give part of it to my landlord?

If your rent is automatically withheld from your paycheck as terms of your employment and given directly to your landlord, then yes, that logic might hold.

However, I'm betting that's not the case.

link
s73v3r_ 2955 days ago
Yet, it was still my choice to live there. And, and this is the most important part, I still earned that money through my work. Having it auto deducted from the paycheck isn't any different than having auto pay set up on my bank account.
link
charleslmunger 2955 days ago
That's the difference - you choose to live there. You can't choose to not be part of a public union, for state jobs that have one. Support for political causes should not be a requirement for employment by the state.
link
s73v3r_ 2955 days ago
Again, yes, you can. You are free to choose your job based on the conditions of the job.
link