| This is false equivalence. The electron app is ostensibly working for your benefit, just in a very inefficient way, not mining a currency using your resources to ship off to someone. You could argue that making users pay for savings in development by their RAM, Disk, CPU, GPU and electricity costs is also bad (and even bad for the planet) but that's a less shady business strategy for saving cost than covertly mining. I have argued that and similar points with varying success at [0]. Then again someone took it upon themselves to downvote this[2] 30 minute comment of mine already and offered no counterpoint so maybe bloatware is what people want and they will go out of their way to justify it. Back to this topic: to stop mining requires stopping being shady and turn it off, to stop burning resources with electron requires huge staff changes, technology changes, mentality changes, etc. and goes against what Joel Spolsky said about rewrite from scratch[1] (but I do feel the irony every time I see Atom or something claim they have now way more performant code by rewriting a part of the program in C++). It's also very unfair IMO to compare pure hearted electron users (whatever you think of people who use it and the tech itself) to someone who stealthily installs malware (which borders on a crime and is way more shady and immoral). Coincidentally I found a very neat app for music conversion/extraction from videos today, it's light, starts instantly, the GUI never lags even for thousands of files, it's total size is 40 megs and I looked into it and it's just ffmpeg dll, some other dll for other media stuff and the main GUI is in Delphi (and to add insult to injury the author is a Pole, which is ironic because I am also a Pole and I was taught Delphi in high school too - as my first language - and use Lazarus from time to time to play around with Pascal and native GUIs again). [0] - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15948290 [1] - https://www.joelonsoftware.com/2000/04/06/things-you-should-... [2] - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17055872 |
Joel at one time was the product manager(?) for Excel. Microsoft also got lambasted for trying to use an internally built cross platform solution to use the same codebase for Mac Office and Windows Office back in the mid 1990s. Microsoft even decided that it was better to use native tooling for both platforms.
There is a difference between "rewriting" and using native tools for each platform. Would you still want something using Java+Swing?