Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by a_imho 2959 days ago
Why would you ever click one of those buttons?
4 comments

They hover up and cover half of the screen on mobile
Not clicking it doesn't stop them from using cookies/tracking you. The box is simply to inform you that they ARE doing it, whether you like it or not.
How is that consent?
Once you are informed you can leave the site if you want to.
Except for cookies are already transmitted to the client device in far too many cases before the disclaimer is displayed. Also I'm not sure blanket agreeing to all (tracking)cookies will be in accordance with GDPR.
The implication is that, now that you know that cookies are used for tracking, remaining on the site is implied consent. Like the omnipresent "this call may be recorded" statement at call centers.

It is an instance of a much broader issue, where contracts are no longer the result of any negotiation, but are a take it or leave it option.

I understand going after each and every website would be impractical, but imo a disclaimer with a button - most probably after the fact the site already transmitted a handful of cookies - does not comply with the spirit of the regulation.

[1] https://www.cookielaw.org/the-cookie-law/

Most people have at least a passing desire for cleanliness and order (the stuff that becomes OCD when out of balance) which compels them to get rid of the banner.
Because that's how you make them go away.