Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by Tinned_Tuna 2970 days ago
Hey!

What's the layman's 2-minute definition of a time crystal?

The name makes it sound very sci-fi, like it might have the ability to travel through time (!)

2 comments

Crystal has repeatable structure over space. Its lattice is the same shape over and over again.

Time crystal is a kind of crystal that has repeatable structure over time. It just means it changes its "shape" in a repeated fashion over time. Usually an external force is required to force a crystal to change its shape over time such as with the piezoelectric effect. Time crystal is supposed to just keep changing its "shape" over time by itself. In the Yale case, the changing of "shape" is the flipping of the nuclear-spin magnetization periodically.

That's a great illustration of repeated structural change over time; admittedly that requires an external power to spin it initially.
So could a time crystal be viewed as a source for time information in a system?
The original idea of time crystal is a material that has periodic structures in time, at the lowest energy state [1]. That means it can have repeated structural change over time by itself at rest. In that case, the crystal itself has an intrinsic periodicity in motion, and can be used as a source of time information.

However, now it seems to be changed to that an external energy source is driving the frequency of the structural change of the crystal over time. Like in the Yale experiment, an external pulsing light shines at the system at certain pulsing frequency and they found the system reverses its nuclear spin at twice as slow as the light's pulsing frequency. There's no intrinsic timing property shown in the crystal, so it cannot be used as a source of time information. I've asked the same question. [2]

[1] https://physics.aps.org/articles/v5/116

[2] https://news.ycombinator.com/reply?id=16997756

Let me know if my attempted synopsis above is helpful or not... I think I can confidently say that the crystal does not travel backwards in time (or forwards in time any faster than the normal rate, as has been pointed out).

However, it is a seemingly miraculous trick of spin systems that we are able to use pulses to effectively reverse the time evolution of the system and produce echoes. When looking at one new pulse sequence which had many pulses, the discoverer of the spin echo (Erwin Hahn) said "With that many pulses I could bring back the Messiah!" [1].

[1, PDF] https://pines.berkeley.edu/sites/default/files/publications/...