Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by tempodox 2967 days ago
This would be even more awesome if the puzzle pieces were curved, so they'd form a Klein bottle when put together.
3 comments

That would be INCREDIBLY awesome, considering that it would require pieces that have a curve in to the 4th dimension (or perhaps just pieces that could pass through each other). A Klein bottle is a 2-dimensional surface cannot be embedded in a 3-dimensional space without crossing.
While this is true mathematically, there is at least one project that emulates Klein bottles in 3D quite credibly:

http://www.kleinbottle.com

Edit: You can even put in some liquid (the “hose” continues through the crossing). The fun part is getting it out again :)

Hey that's the famous Clifford Stoll of Cuckoo's Egg fame.

Glad he is not famous only for that book. As fine as it is.

There are lots of projects that do this (implement a Klein bottle with a crossing).
Even my dad has knit several Klein bottle hats for fun, inspired by one of those projects. I got one as a Christmas present.
I think the flat version is a more authentic representation of the 4-dimensional object. If you were a 2D creature embedded in the surface of a Klein bottle, space would seem flat in every direction... at least until you went out for a walk and found the mirror-image of your house.
I have a 3D jigsaw puzzle that makes a globe (i.e. the Earth) that consists of curved plastic pieces. It shouldn't be too hard to make such a Klein puzzle, though solving it is harder. The globe puzzle includes a small bowl (of the same radius as the finished globe) to assist putting the pieces together; this wouldn't be possible with a klein bottle due to there not being a consistent radius.