Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by manishsharan 2979 days ago
Is this really such a bad thing for developing countries ? In India, for instance , powerful people use twitter to call for rape and murder of their opponents regularly and politicians justify rape. These are just a small minority of people -- however they are extra-ordinarily vocal and their "free speech" scares all the decent people.

Of course , Social Credit score has no place in western liberal democracies but maybe Social Credit score is not a bad idea for developing countries where ignorant people outnumber educated people ,where depraved medieval traditions still hold sway.
2 comments
pradn 2979 days ago
The potential for abuse of a "social score" system seems even higher in countries without strong liberal-democratic traditions or an educated voting population. Politicians in India already abuse their oversight of the police to sidestep the legal system. (The classic case of the "son of the MLA" who commits a crime and gets acquitted because of his father's political power.) It would be easy enough to reduce the social scores for opponents or critics of the politicians in power. Hell, there have been arrests in India based on Facebook posts. Not to mention virtual mobs threatening vocal citizens on Twitter. At least these instances are visible. Someone could silently add some bogus stuff to your "social score" file, just like credit reports can contain false information. A "social score" system would just replicate corruption and illiberality on a large scale. From the perspective of those in power, it would be a good way to control people.
link
manishsharan 2979 days ago
You do make a very good point about the potential for abuse. My vision for this would be be a dispassionate system -- driven by AI and untouched by politics-- that could create/assign the social score. A model could be created by the science community with inputs from the legal system.
link
pradn 2979 days ago
Technology just encodes the ethics of the creator, so we can't hope for apolitical technology.
link
deciplex 2979 days ago
If this isn't just another tool used by the powerful to the oppress the weak then it will be a milestone in human history.

The rich and powerful in China have nothing to fear from this.

link