Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by saas_co_de 2991 days ago
AlphaGo is impressive, but it is an impressive parlor trick not impressive as 'artificial intelligence'

Playing a game with fixed rules and a finite set of potential states is something a computer can do.

Designing the computer that does that is intelligent.

There is no connection between the two and one does not lead to the other.

The fact that some of the people developing 'artificial intelligence' have such a limited understanding of what intelligence is no doubt contributes to the mocking tone of some critics.

1 comments

I'm looking forward to the day when we have a computer that passes the Turing test but comments like yours still show up.
Scott Aaronson: “So this is about the state of the art in terms of man-machine repartee. It seems one actually needs to revise the Turing Test to say that if we want to verify intelligence in a computer, then we need some minimal level of intelligence in the human interrogator.”

https://www.scottaaronson.com/democritus/lec4.html

That’s just the anthropic principle restated.
Plot twist : parent is an AI !