Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by theoh 2989 days ago
>> If mutation is so great, why do mathematicians use recursion so much?

> Huh? Huh?

The deal here is surely that induction and other recursive approaches are conducive to being reasoned about in traditional mathematical contexts (e.g. taking a walk). Mutation is impossible to keep track of, mentally. Though others' mileage will vary on that.
1 comments
ChrisSD 2989 days ago
For the record the "Huh? Huh?" is a quote from the article.
link
theoh 2989 days ago
OK. Downvotes happily accepted; but I think we all operate in "peephole" mode now; the cost of tracing sources back to the original is significant.

There is no karma to be had from complaining about HN's software, and yet it is so very inadequate.

link
dragonwriter 2989 days ago
That it was a quote from the article seemed clear in the post in which the quote was presented, so while I agree that it can be difficult to clearly present quotes in some situations on HN and a good blockquote formatting facility would be preferable, I don't think that's really a problem here.
link
theoh 2989 days ago
As I read the comments on this post, the top reply contains multiple mathematical symbols which aren't rendering on my recent Android phone. You can't pretend that HN has a huge proactive team working on these issues.

I'm loathe to infer that you think that the problem is "me" because I think the underlying question is whether the comments should be a friendly place for people who do not have time or inclination to read the article. You may see that as an appalling, lazy, degeneration in discourse; the reality is that reading the comments without wading through a blog post is a valid tactic. If clearer methods of quoting were available the two or three of us involved here would have wasted less time.

The "engineer-forward" alternative in which everyone strives to speak from a totalizing position of authority is just, frankly (as a technical person myself) unattainable.

link
theoh 2989 days ago
Just to be clear, I am literally saying that IMHO it should be OK to converse in the comments without reading the link in question. If HN can't accommodate this, it's not a friendly platform for humans.
link