Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by johnrichardson 2996 days ago
I don't see the word 'IQ' mentioned anywhere in that article. And yet, it's the single biggest determinant of lifetime success. Unfortunately, it's also highly heritable, so environmental interventions have a fairly marginal effect on it.
1 comments

Unfortunately, it's also highly heritable, so environmental interventions have a fairly marginal effect on it.

(a) The Flynn Effect demonstrates that IQ is quite responsive to environment.

(b) The heritability of a trait is not a measure of the degree to which that trait is genetically determined: Highly heritable traits can be environmently malleable. (The heritability of height is 0.8, but nutrition, childhood sickness, etc. have a huge effect on height.) Conversely, traits with low heritability can be strongly determined, genetically. ("Number of eyes" is a trait with low heritability, for example.)

(c) The measured heritability of IQ isn't especially high. It's usually found to be in the vicinity of 0.3.

Regarding C, isn't that just for children? As I recall it's something like 0.5 or higher for adults.
You're right. Some studies have found it as high as 85%.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heritability_of_IQ