Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by 411mrc 2995 days ago
Thanks. My subtle point was why use tags when you could use search? Search engines index the whole internet - millions of hierarchical file systems of all kinds. Why reinvent file systems?

I don't use Mac. Windows 10 "Cortana" is no match for where Google Desktop was 10 years ago. I rarely use it unless I have to. Google searched the contents. Cortana just searches filenames and tries to route searches to the web. Linux...I don't see anything - Ubuntu has Cortana-like feature, but it's not Google Desktop. It's very odd to go backwards technology-wise.
2 comments
sharpercoder 2995 days ago
Google Desktop was indeed a great solution partially solving the tag problem in Windows. A good tagging system trumps search as you can make the results much better determinate. The ability to create your own namespace and then organize every file into that namespace ensures encapsulation. In a search result, you almost always have to filter out irrelevant items.

Good working search solves the problem pragmatically though :)

link
411mrc 2994 days ago
I am far too lazy to tag every file and I would despise such a system if forced into it. Some files I want to keep realizing I may never need them again. Tagging is a time waste. It's also difficult to anticipate future use and what tags are helpful.

Now a tagging system that could be built over time from search results could be very useful. Apply tags as you go in batches in other words to aid future searches.

If I were designing a new OS, I'd force each piece of software to auto-tag and index the file contents in meta tags and feed it to a global OS search function.

link
sharpercoder 2994 days ago
You assume that you need to tag manually. You assume that you are forced to do so. Currently, it's perfectly possible to put all files in a single folder. Your OS will be happy about that (except maybe some technical limitation of max filecount of a folder).
link
awiesenhofer 2995 days ago
I agree, Cortana is terrible at searching. I use Everything Search [1] coupled with Wox Launcher [2], it's great and just oh so fast!

[1] https://www.voidtools.com/ [2] https://github.com/Wox-launcher/Wox

link