Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by RBerenguel 2994 days ago
I've been peer reviewed once (and waiting for the second) and it was very in depth, giving me a couple of pointers to improve my paper. Field was mathematics, though.
1 comments

sure it depends on field, on journal and on reviewer, and but with a github like interface, and public reviews it will only get better.
Problem is, if the review is public then it means the article is also in the public and some (most) publishers are not OK with that. At least yet, hopefully it will get better.