[brianvaughn]

> However, the amount of large internal changes indicates that as you improve and (most likely) shed unneeded complexity, that there must have been complexity to shed.

The v16 rewrite (dubbed "fiber") wasn't just about cleaning up internals- it was about supporting a fundamentally different type of behavior- asynchronous rendering [1]

> Obviously no one is perfect, and hindsight is 20/20, but for such a "small" (yes, interacting with the dom is actually super duper hard, and edgecases abound) scope, I've seen more large-ish overhauls than I am comfortable with.

To be fair, React supports many more targets than just the DOM. In addition to the DOM- there's react-native, react-art, react-music, react-hardware, etc.

Don't mean to sound argumentative, just wanted to add some info in case there were potential misconceptions. :)

1: https://reactjs.org/blog/2018/03/01/sneak-peek-beyond-react-...

[hardwaresofton]

This is a huge point that I do often miss when I think about react when used for react development...

You're absolutely not being argumentative -- while I still don't think react is the simplest thing to start with, the explanations that have been given so far seem very very reasonable, feel like an asshole for essentially ranting