Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by kbutler 3003 days ago
In an ideal world, lawyers would be advocates seeking to provide a nuanced, human perspective.

In the current world, I think it is more common to be seeking loopholes, weaknesses, and exploits instead.

2 comments

I can see how a person that only knows about law what they read in the headlines could come to that conclusion, but painting lawyers with a broad brush as you have is no more of a generalization than me saying that every Facebook employee is devoid of morals and ethics.
Which lawyers in what context do you see providing that nuanced human perspective?

Corporate law? Their job is keep us from getting sued.

Family law? If you're advocating that human perspective for the opposing party, are you failing your duty to your client?

Prosecutors? Not sure they have that discretion.

General legal services, probate, etc. Doesn't seem that applicable.

Intellectual Property? Human perspective? Unlikely, except maybe the "hard-working inventor" angle.

Defense attorneys? Sure. That could be a good angle - along with any possible opening to exploit.

> Family law? If you're advocating that human perspective for the opposing party, are you failing your duty to your client?

They shouldn't be advocating the opposing party's human perspective in court, but they certainly should be doing it privately to the client. Things will usually work out better for them if they can reach an amicable compromise out of court rather than having to engage in protracted legal battles with their own family.

> Prosecutors? Not sure they have that discretion.

Prosecutors absolutely have that discretion. They don't have to take every case to court and they don't have to seek the harshest allowable punishment for every case they do take to court. They are supposed to be serving the public interest, not seeking to imprison as many people as possible.

Every single point in this post is a broad-brush generalization perpetuated by media stereotypes.
And by limited personal interactions in professional capacities.

I'd love for you to provide countering perspectives from your broader exposure.

Lawyers are essentially social hackers trying to find weaknesses in IP laws and exploiting them for massive profit. It’s essentially court warfare