[wumpus]

I'm all for good review systems. But any review system that labels a large fraction of the submitted code as very deficient indicates that the solution is to act before review.

And I've coded with (and hired) interns and juniors, so it's not just a selection effect. In fact, the worst code I've seen came from a senior engineer, with strong opinions, who wrote the world's most blecherous code. We fired him, but not soon enough.