Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by tomswartz07 3005 days ago
My previous job was in K-12 tech, and I still keep in contact with my old boss.

When I started at that position, the school district (~5k students) was nearly 100% Apple. Nearly every device was the low-cost polycarb Macbook. The district purchased them with a heavy investment from "Classrooms for the Future" program, which covered a large portion of the cost.

Since that time, Apple retired the less expensive model and (same as they still are) trying to position the iPad as a replacement.

Here's the problem though: Students are never going to be effective at long-term use on a tablet. Can you imagine writing a grade 12 level book report on a touch screen? Budget-wise, the district would only be able to purchase the iPads, a case, and that's all. Bluetooth keyboards would not be able to fit in the budget.

Compared, feature for feature, and price- Chromebooks and other traditional low-cost laptops are much more effective to the success of getting technology into students' hands.

In fact, they currently run one of the largest 1-to-1 Linux laptop deployments in the eastern US: https://technology.pennmanor.net/11-laptop-program/

1 comments

You worked for Penn manor? That is pretty cool. At Philadelphia fosscon last year I saw a presentation by the it director at Penn manor (who is who I assume you are talking about). It was a really interesting talk, and it was an impressive achievement. More than just the saving money or more foss use in schools, I thought the program was especially cool for how it taught actual it and computer skills to the children.