Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by andrew-lucker 3009 days ago
Has anyone else encountered the 25 minute ads? Mine was a full episode of some home-improvement show sponsored by Lowes.
4 comments

I've had a few.

It's annoying. I don't use a blocker. I don't skip the ads. Yet youtube shows me some really tedious 25 minute ad (for obscure builing material; for some online god knows what; for some money scam).

I thought it must be some experiment to see how bad ads could get before people like me hit reload or start blocking, because it makes no sense otherwise.

I got one ad that was 10 minutes and couldn't be skipped. I said, yeah screw that noise, copy/paste youtube-dl url
Why don't you install an adblocker, which will block the ads for you?
Some people are labouring under the misapprehension that adblockers are immoral.
I think a 25' ad for a 5' video is a lot more immoral...
I have one, not everything gets blocked.
Make sure you have these rules enabled https://i.imgur.com/S9pCwIc.png

This blocks all twitter/facebook/google/botnet widgets, other tracking elements, all ads, even those on youtube. Highly increases your privacy and browsing experience. I use these rules for so long I even forgot youtube has ads.

I use the latest uBlock Origin with the latest stable Google Chrome on Linux. I have the block lists above (https://i.imgur.com/S9pCwIc.png) enabled, and I'm still getting lots of ads on YouTube. Ads started appearing in 2018, it was fine before.

Any advice how I can get rid of ads on YouTube?

Sometimes I just pull up the youtube app on my iPad no ad blockers work on there. And if I'm making food, I honestly don't worry as much about the ad.

But a 10 minute ad for a 2 minute video? Even then i'll download the video just to spite the entire ad platform, thats insane.

Ah, ok. Try AdGuard, it works great for YT ads.
uBlock has youtube specific rules, check my setup https://i.imgur.com/S9pCwIc.png
Well, one or the other. I don't think it makes a difference.
I've encountered one 25 minute ad on YouTube, I don't recall what it was for though. I laughed and reloaded the page, and off to the races.

I've also encountered a number that range in the 5-10 minute range. I don't use YouTube very often, so I'm not sure how regularly these occur.

Pretty sure 90 minutes the longest I've seen.

Having to wade through at least 5 seconds of ads per video has made me reluctant to use Youtube anymore.