[crispyporkbites]

Is HN now illegal then?

[CodeArtisan]

If a DMCA takedown notice is sent to which HN is not complying, then yes.

[eli]

Ignoring a DMCA takedown isn't illegal, you just potentially lose the "Safe Harbor" protection if someone does decide to sue you.

[LeonM]

I think this is a really good question.

How is this any different than posting a piratebay URL for a pirated movie on HN?

[piracykills]

There's a difference between the page for a pirated movie and the front page of TPB.

Where things really get interesting is info hashes. I could right now post a 160 bit SHA1 hash of any content on the bittorrent DHT and you could obtain it simply by tacking "magnet:?xt=urn:btih:" on the front. So perhaps simply sharing the hash of pirated content with some sort of encouragement could be enough to land you in hot water.

[TeMPOraL]

> How is this any different than posting a piratebay URL for a pirated movie on HN?

It's a link to a site that links to the front page of SciHub, not a particular paper accessed through it.

[toomuchtodo]

What would a magnet link be considered?

[TeMPOraL]

A link directly to content, I presume.

[toomuchtodo]

One of my projects is to serve torrent magnet links as DNS TXT records. Will be interesting to find out what happens.

[GunlogAlm]

It's not different. As in: both are fine. It's not a crime to link to a site that links to content; TPB itself hosts no content. Linking is not a crime.

https://thepiratebay.org

[crispyporkbites]

Then why is thepiratebay blocked at the ISP DNS level by a court order in the UK?

[iggg]

Same reason such thing as a TV license exists.