Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by mathiasben 3034 days ago
these failing pensions are largely due to mismanagement, properly managed these retirement vehicles work as intended. unfortunately in the current climate a large company or even a state government can't resist the temptation to use a massive pension fund for something other than it's intended purpose. One lean quarter and they start eyeing up the 7 billion sitting in the pension fund. I read a book a couple years back that changed my thinking on pensions, before I was of the mind that they never worked, were a massive Ponzi scheme, stealing from young workers, etc... no, pensions work provided they are left alone. http://www.retirementheist.com/
1 comments

"in the current climate"

One of the reasons I'm not a big fan of pensions is precisely that it's not "in the current climate", but a persistent problem over the span of decades. Many of the bills that are now compounding to an unignorable size are trainwrecks decades in the making. It isn't just that they were mismanaged today; they were mismanaged in the 200xs, and the 1990s (much harder to see because the stock market was doing really well up until it wasn't), and the 1980s... it's not hard to think that maybe the fact they worked at all was simply another historical accident of the bizarre just-after-WW2 period, rather than any sort of good idea. We seem to lack angels virtuous enough to be honest about the numbers and to resist dipping into the Honkin' Big Pile o' Money.

I'm convinced it's the changes in the tax laws at the root cause of this. When income over $400k/yr (5 mil in todays money) was taxed at 90% there wasn't the incentive to screw over retirees. The "bizarre just-after-WW2 period" wasn't some fluke it was the result of purposely crafted policies.