Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by gnud 3034 days ago
The server is AGPL. The client is Apache licensed. So I don't see a problem with using the AGPL version in commercial product.

Noone claims that a product using the MySql driver is a derivative work of the MySql server?

Edit: Of course, IANAL...
1 comments
lukev 3034 days ago
That's specifically what the AGPL does (as opposed to the GPL.) The copyleft "infection" is deliberately transmitted via network clients, not just static linking.

So you actually can't release a permissively licensed client for an AGPL server. I mean, they did, clearly, but the AGPL itself would seem to make that inconsistent.

But then none of this has ever been litigated and both the AGPL and GPL themselves are very confusingly worded so shrug.

link
gnud 3034 days ago
As I understand it, with the GPL, you must offer source code under the GPL to everyone you distribute the software to. With the AGPL, the same goes for those that use the software over the network.

So you must offer the source of the database everyone who connects to the database over the network, under the AGPL. But if you deliver a web app, not a database-as-a-service, your users don't connect to the database. And since this database uses the Cassandra protocol, I'd say your web app isn't a derived work of the database in any way.

Of course, that last part is the sticky bit. But if applications using database servers via a well defined protocol are judged to be derived works, we might have other problems - hence the reference to MySql in my first post.

link
snuxoll 3034 days ago
Requiring GPL’d software to function means your product is a derivative work, full stop as far as the spirit and letter of the license is concerned. Using it over a network instead of linking against it doesn’t change this, if you depend on MySQL or any of the forks and distribute your software it must be made available under a GPL-compatible license. The requirements of the AGPL become clear in this regard as well; network use is distribution with the AGPL - incorporating AGPL’d software into your application means you must consider your entire application as licensed under the AGPL or compatible license.

MongoDB muddied the waters here by deciding to interpret the AGPL differently, but I wouldn’t risk your business on it.

link