Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by ntzm 3027 days ago
I don't know of any zionist communists at all
4 comments

I feel a little dirty getting into this thread, but surely you've heard of Kibbutz? Many early Zionists imagined Israel as an idealised Jewish-Marxist utopia.

Of course for every Zionist that was socialist, there was another that was ant-communist, and for every communist that was Jewish there were many more that were anti-semitic. But don't let that stop the conspiracy nuts.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kibbutz

Close enough? Really don't see that hijacking art any time soon though.

Those are socialists! Remember that millions of people have died in the last century because of that subtle distinction.
Are you talking about the century where (all attributes based on self-identification) a realm ruled by a socialist party was waging war against socialist republics ruled by a communist party? Doesn't really sound like they were fighting over semantic pedantry. Or maybe they were, and they were just incredibly good at hiding it.

In the context of an alleged "art hijacking", I say it doesn't matter at all.

Yes, I was thinking about the different kinds of socialists and communists killing each other. (Edit: but I’m not talking just about state vs. state, within a country different factions were not always nice to each other.)
> I don't know of any zionist communists at all

I met them yesterday with the vegan nazis and the irredentist panafricanists - but you don't hang out at the cool parties !

There actually are "vegan nazis". Hitler himself was one.
Maybe it's a redundancy then :P
Sounds like some cool band names ;)
Hitler is the most well known vegetarian.
Likewise every communist I've encountered has been staunchly anti-Israel.