Y
Hacker News
new
|
ask
|
show
|
jobs
by
ChristianBundy
3031 days ago
cd is part of your shell, so trying to invoke cd from another program would be like opening a new browser tab from another program. It's an internal feature without an outward-facing API.
1 comments
qubex
3031 days ago
There's no reason why one shouldn't be able to invoke the chdir system call and implement the same behaviour.
link
chc
3031 days ago
Well, I mean, a program can call chdir() and it works exactly as it's supposed to, but it only affects
that program
, not a different program.
link
gowld
3031 days ago
Allowing any process to arbitrarily modify the state of another process would be a disaster for stability and security.
link
colejohnson66
3031 days ago
Isn’t that what a debugger does?
link
Someone
3030 days ago
Yes, and it is a disaster for stability and security. The designers of
dtrace
worked hard on the stability part. See, for example, the section on DIF safety in
https://www.cs.princeton.edu/courses/archive/fall04/cos518/p...
.
link