[outsideoflife]

Could you elaborate on how this is a restriction on freedom of speech? How is an 'information site' affected? Take HN for example, when I signed up they didn't even ask my name. They probably log IP addresses and would be entitled to, for the purposes of analyzing malicious use.

[peoplewindow]

It's all PII. People post personal details about their lives here, some use their real names as their username, the site asks for email addresses, how is it not PII?

As for IPs. Any website could claim they need IP addresses for analyzing malicious use. So either it'll be a new cookie law in which they all use the vagueness of the new rules to loophole themselves out, or the EU will decide that this is only "reasonable" sometimes. The law effectively says nothing so whether or not HN would be entitled to store this data is essentially undefined.

Here's what will really happen to HN - nothing. But Google will get huge fines for doing exactly the same thing, and everyone will be left wondering if they're next.

[outsideoflife]

> People post personal details about their lives here

Which they explicitly choose to do

> some use their real names as their username

Which is not required to use the site

> the site asks for email addresses

But you don't have to give one. If you do give one it is only used for password resets. Write that in your privacy policy and keep the email safe.

> Any website could claim they need IP addresses for analyzing malicious use

Yes they can, and the law allows it. Don't sell them to data aggregators and put it in your privacy policy why you are keeping it. If you don't want to then send the logs to /dev/null

> or the EU will decide

The courts will decide.

> The law effectively says nothing so whether or not HN would be entitled to store this data is essentially undefined.

What do you want from the EU? A law that references the internet protocol explicitly, and every possible use of it? What happens when the protocol changes, or someone invents a new protocol, or a new way of exploiting it? Pass another law that says the same thing? Laws in the EU are generally principle based for exactly this reason, they age much better.

> Here's what will really happen to HN - nothing

Because they are doing nothing wrong!