Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by IncRnd 3032 days ago
> This is a factor of 4 improvement!

This is a common mistake. It should read, "This is a factor of 3 improvement!"

x+x+x+x is an improvement over x of 3x not of 4x. The improvement factor is 3.

2 comments

It's 3x faster than, but 4x as fast as.
Yes
I am not a native speaker, so I was always under impression that "factor of K larger" means something was X and became K * X (e.g. the multiplicative factor was 1 and became X). Can I read somewhere about the correct usage?
www.wikihow.com/Calculate-Percentage-Increase

The general equation for an increased quantity from A to B is

  increase = B - A
So a percentage increase is

  increase * 100
not

  (increase + A) * 100
but I am not talking about the percentage increase I am talking about increase "by a factor of X" that is X = B/A.

See: https://ell.stackexchange.com/a/52747

Maybe my problem is that I am missing "by".

You are exactly talking about percentages.

B/A is the percentage of the new value relative to the old.

(B-A)/A is the percentage of the increase of the value.

This is algebra not English.

1) You start out with one rock. 2) You add another rock, getting a pile of two rocks. 3) The rock pile size is now 200% of the original size. But, the increase of the rock pile size is 100%. 4) According to the rules of algebra, 100% = 1. In this case 100% = 1 rock, since the unit under discussion is rocks.

They absolutely are not talking about percentages. They're talking about factors. A factor is a term in a multiplication. In standard US English, increasing something by a factor means to multiply it by that number. Even the GMAT uses that phrase in that way. You absolutely can split hairs on this and the phrasing can be confusing but it is absolutely understood that "increased by a factor of 4" means to multiply by 4. If one was talking in terms of percentages, they would say something like "increased by 300%".
>* increasing something by a factor means to multiply it by that number*

That's absolutely wrong... When you multiply something you scale it by a factor. When you add to something you increase it.

1) 4A is 400% of A.

2) 4A in an increase of 300%.

3) 4A is an increase of 3A.

4) 4A is an increase of a factor of 3.

In the most charitable interpretation you are confusing the terms of exponential growth with linear scaling and misapplying from one to the other. A growth factor is not the same as an increase in a factor.

I forgot the division in that post, and I can't edit it. See the post below. Sorry.