Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by edo 3044 days ago
What made Google wave so great to you? (Even better than slack/Discord/Trello)?
2 comments

It was the complete package, encompassing all of:

- That communication could be both synchronous (like chat) and asynchronous (like email) and you could use whichever worked best for you at the time. You could even switch in the middle of a thread- maybe it stared out asynchronous, but then both people were online and decided to have a conversation.

- Threads were a better way of breaking up topics than channels

- The ability to post a document and then have people comment on it let you basically incorporate Google Docs-style document revision into your chat application, but like the other comment says, the comments were a first-class citizen of the interface, rather than bubbles that are totally out of context

- I like real-time chats, where you could see the individual characters the other person was typing. This, admittedly, is an aesthetic preference I know not everyone shares.

Some people hated real-time typing, but it made interactions feel even more immediate than Slack.

I also like that comments were a first-class citizen; part of the document. You could have an in-line conversation about a paragraph, then distill the results into the text and delete the conversation. Comments weren't another "mode" like they are in Google Docs; they were just document bubbles nested in a parent document bubble.

I've apparently flip-flopped on this; looking at a post I wrote at the time, I thought it felt wrong to delete comments.