Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by macintux 3040 days ago
> faster than any other

Are you sure? Someone just did an interesting analysis (admittedly, very small data space but a long-term test), found that Waze claims faster routes than they typically achieve.

Update: Ah, @dogecoinbase linked to it: https://arturrr.com/2018/02/19/navigation-apps/

1 comments

I am here providing an anecdotal story.

Zurich Switzerland -> Austrian Alps

Heavy traffic, incidents along the road, gridlock ...> Waze got us there FASTEST.

"ATTENTION" "WAZE HAS JUST FOUND A FASTER ROUTE".

Competed against iPhone & Google Maps.

Same way return drive. ... So two data points I guess.

Austrian Alps -> Zurich

Plus ... I use it daily... So three data points then.

It's entirely possible you're right, but I don't see how on any individual trip you can assert any solution achieved the best time, unless you have 3 different drivers to take each proposed route (and even then, there's enough variability to make it suspect unless you do it over a long enough period of time).