Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by Bishonen88 3058 days ago
I was intrigued by the title of this post as I was looking for some nice django+d3 combinations for data viz but ... A hosted table with a bar chart? That's new.

I don't really see the audience for this. In the business world, no one will be willing to host their precious, sensitive data on some unknown server. For private use, I'd argue that one either creates a table programmatically in html or simply does it in excel if it's just something small. While we're on the topic of excel, I reckon one could recreate this app with VBA to look identical or near identical within less than 24h (possibly 3h-8h?).

Then comes the description itself - Stephen Few might get a small headache reading it:

> tables present all the actual data so readers feel more confident they’re seeing the source information.

As opposed to what, charts? What else do charts show if not "actual" data?

> Tables also allow you to rank items and show the relative magnitude of any item versus the rest.

Do charts not have exactly the same property? The relative magnitude of one item is easier seen in a well made chart than a table.

> Lastly, tables have a high information density: they allow you display a large amount of data in a limited space. Imagine the above table as a bar chart and how unwieldy that would be

The above table does in fact contain a bar chart. Doesn't seem so unwieldy to me. Charts, in my opinion, can have a much higher information density which is still comprehensible than tables - a scatter plot with 2 series each made of 1.000 items might be eye-opening if done right (and data has some trends etc.) - the same data displayed as a table, however, would take minutes/hours to digest.

1 comments

Thanks for checking it out. The use case is blogging and content marketing. That's what we use it for at least.