Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by KirinDave 3067 days ago
Why is this desirable?

IPFS nodes don't really rehost content for any substantial period of time (especially the gateway) so you're still stuck with some major problems:

1. You're still hosting off your IPFS node. This isn't worse, but it isn't better. You need to have a node and it needs to have connectivity.

2. IPNS resolution is glacial and it's a known issue without resolution currently. So any gateway trying to resolve your current version of the IPFS-hosted status page through a gateway using IPNS can often end up waiting seconds (sometimes even tens of seconds) for name resolution, giving the impression of a downed status page.

Sadly, IPFS is more of a decentralized presentation and perhaps caching framework. It doesn't really achieve the goal of decentralized storage until there is some reliable way to persist the data on the network beyond immediate use. Pinning services exist, but most seem quite expensive to me.
1 comments
prophesi 3067 days ago
1. They're hoping that FileCoin will resolve that issue. Akin to Storj and Siacoin, people will offer to host (aka pin) content on their IPFS gateway node in return for FileCoins, and the market will decide the price.

2. In the meantime, you can set up a script to update your DNS TXT record to point to the most recent IPFS hash. I've got a static site generator that does this upon the completion of a build.

link
KirinDave 3065 days ago
It's really too bad that anyone still thinks FileCoin is not a deeply flawed (if not outright scammy) endeavor. The only reason it isn't more widely decried is that the IPFS folks have a lot of goodwill in the community.

But it's a bad coin.

As for your #2, I don't use this solution because of propagation times. Instead, I use an nginx proxy that rewrites incoming requests on a specific path to root on IPFS node. When I rebuild, I rebuild that site config there.

But tbh, I'm going to undo that. I get absolutely nothing for being part of IPFS and there's effectively no reason to host content there. It's a DHT and while that's cool, it's actually substantially less efficient than alternatives.

I've been enthusiastic about IPFS because it's a neat white paper, but after using it for months I've concluded it's a tech demo with no real direction to go other than a deeply flawed cryptocurrency.

link